Michael Stock said, “In general, all propellers which are not in-flight adjustable are a compromise between take-off and climb performance (power) and cruise flight (speed, endurance). They cannot work at maximum efficiency in both flight regimes.”
He added, “Propeller thrust for take-off and climb can be up to 30% higher if the propeller blade angle is perfectly adjusted at all times.”
The problem is that FAA, by regulation in place since 2004, only allows a ground-adjustable prop. The agency’s thinking 15 years ago revolved around “safe, simple, easy to fly” intended for all aircraft in the LSA category. That philosophy has not changed; they continue to repeat the line as a guide to their proposed regulation.
However, a ground adjustable prop can be done poorly. Mistakes can be made if the person making the adjustment does not have training or experience.
Safety Argument
When LAMA personnel went to Washington DC to advocate on behalf of pilots and producers in the light aircraft sector, we knew the argument could not be that we wanted an in-flight adjustable prop to go faster. The truth is that many LSA can already hit the speed limit enforced by the current regulation.
“It’s not about speed; it’s about being able to safely get in or out of a shorter field yet still cruise at whatever speed the airframe was designed to reach,” we told FAA. A personal experience departing the Sun ‘n Fun Paradise City airstrip brought home the safety point. The 1,400-foot grass strip should be more than adequate for a LSA but the particular model (Glasair’s now discontinued Merlin LSA) had been fitted with a cruise prop for the long flight from Washington State to Florida. Since this was a typically heavy prototype, this left the design with insufficient thrust on a shorter turf runway.
To their credit, the FAA executives hearing the argument rather quickly agreed; after all, single lever control does not increase pilot workload therefore maintaining the “safe, simple, easy to fly” baseline.
“An in-flight adjustable propeller for LSA should be controlled automatically and not require operation by the pilot,” explained Michael Stock. “An automated blade pitch control system for LSA must provide a 100% fail-safe behavior at all times.”
Fuel injection and ignition of the iS-series of Rotax engines is controlled by a redundant Engine Control Unit (ECU) that uses two individual sets of injectors/spark plugs per cylinder. The ECU controls the fuel-to-air mixture and the ignition timing electronically to optimize fuel consumption and engine performance. The ECU also monitors all engine parameters continuously.